My Projection Collection:
Compare Projections
Kharchenko-Shabanova vs. Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
| Kharchenko-Shabanova | Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical | |
|---|---|---|
| Creator | A. S. Kharchenko, A. I. Shabanova (1951) | Waldo Tobler (1993) |
| Group | Cylindric | Cylindric |
| Property | Compromise | Compromise |
| Other Names | — | — |
| Remarks | Created by Kharchenko, revised by Shabanova in 1952. | — |
| recommended comparisons | Tobler Cylindrical 2 | Kharchenko-Shabanova |
|
This pairing is among the list of recommended pairings – but why? While very much alike at first glance, in direct comparision the differences become quite obvious. |
||
1. Comparison: Physical Map – scaled to fit
2. Comparison: Political Map – scaled to fit
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
3. Comparison: Silhouette Map – scaled to fit
Kharchenko-Shabanova Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
4. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 30° – scaled to fit
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
Kharchenko-Shabanova Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
5. Comparison: Physical Map – scaled to same width
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
6. Comparison: Political Map – scaled to same width
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
7. Comparison: Silhouette Map – scaled to same width
Kharchenko-Shabanova Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
8. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 30° – scaled to same width
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
Kharchenko-Shabanova Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
9. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 15° – scaled to fit
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
Kharchenko-Shabanova Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
10. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 15° – scaled to same width
Kharchenko-Shabanova
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical
Kharchenko-Shabanova Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Tobler’s variant 2 of Miller Cylindrical Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung


