My Projection Collection:
Compare Projections
Winkel-Denner II (40°) vs. Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
Winkel-Denner II (40°) | Winkel Tripel Bartholomew | |
---|---|---|
Creator | Peter Denner (2023) | Oswald Winkel (1921) |
Group | Lenticular | Lenticular |
Property | Compromise | Compromise |
Other Names |
|
|
Remarks | Arithmetic mean of the equirectangular (with φ0 = 40°) and Aitoff projections for the x values, and of the equirectangular and (scaled up) Hammer projections for the y values. Originally presented in a thread in the mapthematics forum. Also see the blogpost The Winkel-Denner Projections. |
This version was designed by John Bartholomew (about 1955), it uses 40° North and South as standard parallels instead of 50°28´ in Winkel’s original design. |
recommended comparisons | — | Winkel Tripel BOPC Winkel Tripel |
1. Comparison: Physical Map – scaled to fit
2. Comparison: Political Map – scaled to fit
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°)](/img/political/winkel-var-denner-2b.png)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew](/img/political/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.png)
3. Comparison: Silhouette Map – scaled to fit
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Silhouette Map](/img/rot/winkel-var-denner-2b.png)
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Silhouette Map](/img/gruen/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.png)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
4. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 30° – scaled to fit
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-30/winkel-var-denner-2b.jpg)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-30/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.jpg)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
5. Comparison: Physical Map – scaled to same width
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°)](/img/jpg-w/winkel-var-denner-2b.jpg)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew](/img/jpg-w/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.jpg)
6. Comparison: Political Map – scaled to same width
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°)](/img/political-w/winkel-var-denner-2b.png)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew](/img/political-w/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.png)
7. Comparison: Silhouette Map – scaled to same width
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Silhouette Map](/img/rot-w/winkel-var-denner-2b.png)
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Silhouette Map](/img/gruen-w/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.png)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Silhouette Map c Tobias Jung
8. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 30° – scaled to same width
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-30-w/winkel-var-denner-2b.jpg)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-30-w/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.jpg)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
9. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 15° – scaled to fit
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-15/winkel-var-denner-2b.jpg)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-15/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.jpg)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
10. Comparison: Tissot Indicatrix, 15° – scaled to same width
Winkel-Denner II (40°)
![Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-15-w/winkel-var-denner-2b.jpg)
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew
![Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix](/img/tissot-15-w/winkel-tripel-bartholomew.jpg)
Winkel-Denner II (40°) Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung
Winkel Tripel Bartholomew Tissot Indicatrix c Tobias Jung